The Most Reliable Teacher

Our current seminar on writing food memoir, The Hungry I, has me knee deep in reading memoir and reading about memoir. I’m halfway through Judith Barrington’s book, “Writing the Memoir,” for the third time.

Ms. Barrington is a poet. She levies a merciless eye for detail to accessing, imagining, shaping and constructing personal history. Yet, she has boundless compassion for the courage it takes to use the “I word”.

Her tone alternates between the spare and the lyrical, with occasional bursts of language that make everything — the soup that is simmering as I read, the snow that is falling outside the window, the itch of the blanket on my lap, the warmth of the dog’s head on the blanket reminding me that its time for dinner — more vivid.

I swoon for a second — why didn’t I read this before I wrote a memoir? And then I remember, well, I did read it before, and then after, and now after again and perhaps before another. Writing changes how you read as certainly as reading changes how you write.

In a world of precious few mentors, other people’s books remain the most reliable teachers, writes Ms. Barrington:

“Today, the would-be writer must patch together an apprenticeship. If you are serious about the craft, your learning may be helped along by various writing teachers, through writing programs or workshops, or sometimes through less formal meetings or correspondence. If you are very lucky, you may find one teacher to see you through all or part of a long apprenticeship, but more likely you will work with several teachers, as well as peer groups that offer support and critique. But remember that extensive reading is probably the most important ingredient of your apprenticeship, whether or not you have a teacher. You will never become a good writer if you urgently want to write but do not have an equal passion of reading.”

3 Responses to “The Most Reliable Teacher”

  1. Shalini January 16, 2012 at 4:03 pm # Reply

    I love this. There have been so many times I’ve read lots and lots, and written nothing. This reminds me that in order to keep writing I always have to keep reading. As for those other things such as mentors and apprenticeships and communities of people to help each other along, those are invaluable, too. Beautiful image of writing with a fountain pen.

  2. mindy January 16, 2012 at 4:11 pm # Reply

    Miss Barrington’s quote most definitely provided me with an “aha moment” as well. I never thought to use the reading of someone else’s good writing as an instructional tool for my own “good writing.” Such a basic concept (duh!), and yet I missed it. I have learned my lesson and particularly like William Zinsser’s book. He is a wonderful story teller and an equally effective teacher.

  3. Rachel Gaffney January 17, 2012 at 11:22 am # Reply

    thank you for sharing this… Lovely.

Leave a Reply